This is a 5 cent coin plate for a classic Bally Skill Roll Machine and other machines like them.
This is a close reproduction but not quite authentic to the original. The original was a stainless steel plate with then a screen print of the house / cent value on it.
This plate is available in the same size and look but with the house and cent value recessed into the plate instead of a decal.
I have no control over the price as set by Shapeways but opened various materials.
Gray Plastic - for a close look and cheapest option
Aluminiun - mid range could possibly be polished
Polished Brass / Bronze - which you could get nickel plated.
For the metal options you could infill the recess with a red paint to level off and get a close to original look. This maybe possible for the plastic one as well but maybe clearcoat first.
Hope it helps