I purchased one of these in black. I'm not planning on keeping it on permanently but only when I feel I need the added protection. I'd give this product 4 out 5. It seams to protect the sides of the the watch with some added screen protection due to the raised edge around the screen. Its also really not bulky at all and actually barley noticeable that there's even a case on it. It's not really tough to put on and take off but I will be cautious with how often I take it off and on again. The black is a little grainy feeling witch I'm not a big fan off but I can live with it. It does tend to catch on fabric easily though. All in all, I think paired with a screen protector it will keep my watch protected.